Search This Blog

Friday, September 4, 2015

1B: Ralph Ellison (1914-1994), the Invisible Man, and Jeff Wall

Ralph Ellison (March 1,1914--April 16,1994)
A PBS American Masters profile of Ralph Ellison offers a good  overview of his life.  You can follow it with brief biographies at bio.com and the Library of Congress, and an interview that was conducted with Ellison and published in the Paris Review in 1955. NPR commemorated his birth with a broadcast on May 30, 2014. (Different sources list his birth year as 1913, 1914, and 1915.) Here's part of what Ellison had to say in the Paris Review interview about the "Battle Royal" section that we read from Invisible Man:

I don’t know whether I’m getting this over or not. Let’s put it this way: Take the “Battle Royal” passage in my novel, where the boys are blindfolded and forced to fight each other for the amusement of the white observers. This is a vital part of behavior pattern in the South, which both Negroes and whites thoughtlessly accept. It is a ritual in preservation of caste lines, a keeping of taboo to appease the gods and ward off bad luck. It is also the initiation ritual to which all greenhorns are subjected. This passage states what Negroes will see I did not have to invent; the patterns were already there in society so that all I had to do was present them in a broader context of meaning. In any society there are many rituals of situation which, for the most part, go unquestioned. They can be simple or elaborate, but they are the connective tissue between the work of art and the audience.

There are two websites that provide information about the history of the Battle Royal: Jim Crow Museum of Racist Memorabilia at Ferrus State University, and SB Nation Caged Seats

Invisible Man, the novel from which "Battle Royal" is taken, has found itself on the banned book list.  The Los Angeles Times reported the news, Sept. 19, 2013, in "Ralph Ellison's Invisible Man Banned in North Carolina" It appears that, based on a Los Angeles Times article, Sept. 24, 2013,  the ban may be rescinded.  After you read "Battle Royal" (or Invisible Man) can you think of a reason why someone would want it banned?


Invisible Man was published in 1952, a novel that Ellison began writing in 1945.  Thought by many to be among the 20 greatest novels of the 20th century, it would be Ellison's only novel published in his lifetime. However, he would go one to write noteworthy short stories and essays with music being a frequent topic. Ellison began his life as a student at Tuskegee Institute studying music in 1933.


Page 1 of the Prologue from Invisible Man.



A 28 minute video interview with Ellison, produced by New York public television.
To see the video with Closed Caption click on this, or click on the YouTube icon for the above video.

Farah Griffin, above, discusses Ralph Ellison. Griffin, an author,
 is the William B. Ransford Professor of English
 and Comparative Literature and African American Studies
 at Columbia University. This video can also be found here. 

In fall 2010, Joey Naranjo, an English 1B student, told me how much he liked Jeff Wall, a great contemporary photographer. I think highly of Wall, too, and told Joey of this one image of Wall's that was inspired by Ralph Ellison's Invisible Man.  Now that we are reading "Battle Royal," a selection from Invisible Man, I wanted to show you some of Wall's work and one photograph, in particular.


This is the room, as envisioned by Jeff Wall, that the Invisible Man made for himself underground.  Wall's photographs are often staged: he designs sets and poses individuals, in scenes that pay homage to other works of art and literature, as he does here.  His works are then mounted in lightboxes, so large that you could step into it and become a part of the moment. Click on After "Invisible Man" by Ralph Ellison, the Preface, 1999-2000 to get a larger reproduction and its dimensions.  Here's a video of Jeff Wall talking about his 
"After Invisible Man, by Ralph Ellison, The Prologue": 




Though the following words are not included in our anthology, they are pertinent to understanding Ellison's protagonist and Wall's photograph.  For your reading pleasure, from Ellison's Invisible Man, the protagonist describes the place where he makes his home:

My hole is warm and full of light.  Yes, full of light. I doubt if there is a brighter spot in all New York than this hole of mine, and I do not exclude Broadway.  Or the Empire State Building on a photographer's dream night.  But that is taking advantage of you.  Those two spots are among the darkest of our whole civilization--pardon me, our whole culture (an important distinction, I've heard)--which might sound like a hoax, or a contradiction, but that (by contradiction, I mean) is how the world moves: Not like an arrow, but a boomerang. (Beware of those who speak of the spiral of history; they are preparing a boomerang.  Keep a steel helmet ready.) I know; I have been boomeranged across my head so much that I now can see the darkness of lightness.  And I love light.  Perhaps you'll think it strange that an invisible man should need light, desire light, love light.  But maybe it is exactly because I am invisible.  Light confirms my reality, gives birth to my form. (6-7) 

"Invisible Man: A Memorial to Ralph Ellison" by Elizabeth Catlett. Situated in Harlem in 2003 at Riverside Park at 150th Street, across from Ellison's former home of 50 years. Follow this link to see a short film about "Invisible Man: A Memorial to Ralph Memorial" and biographical notes about the author.

Something to consider: How well does each work of art, the Jeff Wall photograph and Elizabeth Catlett's sculpture, above, capture the character of the Invisible Man, as presented in the selection "Battle Royal" from Ellison's novel, Invisible Man? You can post your response by clicking on  "comments."  I look forward to reading what you have to say.
Ralph Ellison U.S. Stamp, above.
First day of issue, February 18, 2014, Kansas City.
Ellison is remembered by scholars and writers at a USPS site.
An excerpt of one remembrance appears below.

"Ralph Ellison loved letters. His rich correspondence began in 1933 after he rode the rails of Depression freights from Oklahoma City to Tuskegee Institute in Alabama. There, he wrote letters to his mother, always in his own hand. In New York City, where he moved in 1936, she remained his favored correspondent. By then he composed on the typewriter, often scrawling a P.S. in the margins or on the back of the envelope.

"In his last years, though an early, passionate aficionado of the personal computer, he held off switching to email. He preferred to print out his letters, perhaps add a note or two in his bold script, pick out appropriate stamps from the stash on his desk, and walk the letters to the mailbox. An American man of letters, he loved the letter as a form of communication, and the U.S. Mail® as a network of conveyance between writer and reader."

---John F. Callahan, Morgan S. Odell Professor of Humanities at Lewis & Clark College and the editor of Ellison’s posthumously published volumes of work.  More of Callahan's remembrances of Ellison and that of other writers and scholars can be found here. 



12 comments:

  1. In both "Battle Royal" and the Invisible Man, Wall seems to put a sense of knowing. In both stories we find that the character knows who he is, and how he fits into society.

    Kary Calderon
    english 1B m/w 7-9

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Kary,
    Thoughtful words. I want to follow-up on your remarks in-class.
    --Christopher McCabe

    ReplyDelete
  3. HEY PROF!

    um do you remember what we talked about after class today? i just had another thought. have you read the crucible by aurthur miller? for the main character in battle royal wouldn't he be like the person on trail who's caught between the father and the daughter? because the main character in battle royal wants to go toward that light to be known, but as he get closer it would kill him more so he is forced to circle around that light and even if he wanted to he can't go back into the darkness cause he once he stepped out in to the light, he's known and going back into the darkness would be like disappearing and leaving no traces of ever going to the light, but he's already burned by the light so he can't go back into the darkness

    ReplyDelete
  4. It seems as though Jeff Wall translated the character’s fondness for light as some sort of literal obsessive compulsive translation. I think that the character in the book is using the light as a positive reference to things in his life or as a manifestation of who he is or wants to be. Perhaps he says that his home is full of light because it is his safe haven and where he is visible or true to himself. He can self reflect and not fall into the background as he would out in the world. He is his own boss. In class we talked about how he was told to basically nod and smile. This would definitely make a person vanish into the background and seem invisible.

    -Jennifer Li
    English 1B 7-9

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think the character in his pre-invisible days had the light within himself until his grandfather burnt it out making him feel invisible. In public, he had to blend in with the background and say yesses and be agreeable. Therefore, I think Wall's over-exaggeration with the light bulbs could possibly translate to the character's need to have all those light bulbs shining down on him so that he could still see himself as visible, tangible and capable human being.

    Donna Momsen
    English 1B MW 7-9

    ReplyDelete
  6. I thought back to around the time "The Battle Royal was written. When he refers to himself as "invisible," it could be bringing some sort of awareness to the fact that he is not a citizen of the united states. Before the 15th amendment, you were not considered a citizen even if you were born in the united states. I just thought back to this period of time and connected it to the history.

    Rimar D-West
    English 1B MW 7-9

    ReplyDelete
  7. This is an hilaroius coincidence. I used precisely the same photo for a slide in my presentation about "The Invisible Man" that I gave in my African-American Sociology class during the Spring Semester 2011.

    ReplyDelete
  8. When I read "Battle Royal" I imagined a sensible and sophisticated man in a chaotic environment. The picture in the hole is fitting with the passage because I think it shows the true nature of the chracter. Not solitary and lonely, but rather someone who shines brighter by his own devices and on his own terms.

    M. Hernandez
    Eng 1B M-Th 1030-0130

    ReplyDelete
  9. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  10. The photograph Walls took perfectly depicts how the character is described in the story. He is a young man who is in his own space filled with light. Many of us would find this solitude as lonely however the protagonist of the story lets the lights guide him to a better place. This is what I believe Catletts's sculpture is also depicting, a young man who despite being invisible is still going on because of his love and desire for light. This light is his being despite the hole it is filling. This is a character who is invisible yet can still appreciate and shine despite his invisibility to the society around him.
    The protagonist of the story "Battle Royal" seems to be a man who is caught in a hectic and confusing situation. The story was quite difficult to read, it had moments that were sickening yet they are truthful because this is how African Americans were treated. The men in this boxing match were treated more like animals than human beings and though this was hard to read, it represents perfectly what literature is suppose to do. A literary piece of work is suppose to leave you questioning and looking deep within yourself to truly accept what is being told on the pages. Ellison does a beautiful job at having readers not only question what or why these things are happening but he is also telling a story that allows readers to react. Reaction is important in literature because reacting is the first step to understanding and maybe even changing perspectives. This is why I do not agree with the book being banned. Banning literature takes away from the beauty of literature. If all literature that allows students to react and get upset or even question things around them is yanked from book shelves then what is the point of studying literature?

    Cynamon Mantley
    English 1B T-Th 9:45-11:50

    ReplyDelete
  11. Cynamon,
    When I read "Battle Royal," it never fails to consume me. It is the strongest of writing. Though it has been 22 years since I read Ellison's novel Invisible Man, from which "Battle Royal" is taken, it has stayed with me. I need to read it again.

    Christopher McCabe

    ReplyDelete
  12. The photograph by Wall is a perfect representation of this scene in Ellison's Invisible Man. In this scene, the protagonist had embraced his "invisibility," because he no longer cared how people viewed him and realized that his constant aim to please people was blinding him from the truth. The protagonist and narrator of the story did not explicitly define what it meant to be invisible, but explains how he was invisible because people did not see him for who he actually was and that society viewed him as insignificant. The entire story of the Invisible Man takes place as the narrator explains how he got to that point in his life, and how he ends up accepting his invisibility by realizing his insignificance. The hundreds of light bulbs in the room represents that the embracing of his invisibility gave him a sense of enlightenment, because he now looked at the world as it actually was and did not live in blindness as he was previously. This enlightenment brought him to redefine his grandfather's advice by no longer trying to please people and instead to transcend beyond society's evils and live life without being controlled. I suggest that everyone who has the opportunity should read this book because it reveals some harsh truth about society and makes you realize how much society has progressed from the times of racial segregation to now.

    Kevin Samkian
    English 1B T-TH
    9:45-11:50

    ReplyDelete