Joyce Carol Oates on the cover of Newsweek, December 11, 1972 |
"If you’re not afraid of much in life, you haven’t experienced life yet! There is much, much to be fearful of, though perhaps it is not a good idea to know this. The disasters that you might expect are not likely to happen, but others will, totally unexpected ones. Out of nowhere, they will come, and you will say, But I had no idea. That is the point: you have no idea. Just wait."
--Joyce Carol Oates, in The New Yorker, June 24, 2013
Here are 10 Tips on Writing from Oates.
Oates on "Where are You Going, Where Have You Been?"
The inspiration for Arnold Friend of "'Where are You Going, Where Have You Been?' was Charles Schmid, the Pied Piper of Tucson:"
"[Oates's story is] loosely based upon the true story of Charles 'Smitty' Schmid (b. 1942; d. 1975), a serial killer in Tucson, Arizona, called the 'Pied Piper of Tucson.' He was able to lure girls into being with him, partly because he came from wealth. He had a house on his parents’ property, at which he often held parties. He wore pancake makeup and drew a mole on his face to make a 'beauty mark.' He died his reddish-brown hair black, and was known to have gotten several girls to dye their hair for him. He stood between 5’3’’ and 5’4’’ tall, but stuffed his boots with wadded up newspapers and crushed cans to make himself taller. In the end, he killed 3 girls (aged 17, 15, 13), burying their bodies in the desert. He was finally caught through a confession of a former confidante. When he killed the first girl, Alleen Rowe, he lured her out of her house while a friend of his waited in the car. "Smitty" was said to have virtually talked his victim into his car. He also claimed to have some hallucinogenic or psychic powers. He was convicted and sentenced to life in prison; he was killed in 1975 by other inmates."--by Michael Kiggins, Nashville State Community College, at http://ww2.nscc.edu/kiggins_m/4-oates.pdf
Oates and Bob Dylan
Oates has said that her story, "Where are You Going, Where Have You Been?", was inspired by the Tucson murderer described above, not Bob Dylan, though she dedicated her story to him. However, she did say that she was listening to Dylan at the time that she wrote the story. Here she is asked about the Dylan connection:
She has also written "Dylan at 60," a reflection on his career. Now for some Dylan himself, around the time Oates wrote "Where are You Going, Where Have You Been?"
Bob Dylan at the Newport Folk Festival, 1963-65
Bob Dylan singing "It's All Over Now, Baby Blue" in a London hotel
from the film "Don't Look Back" (1965). Dylan starts singing
"It's All Over Now, Baby Blue" (at 2:20) after Donovan sings.
Some say that Dylan's song shares a mood with the Oates story. Do you agree?
It's All Over Now, Baby Blue
You must leave now, take what you need, you think will last
But whatever you wish to keep, you better grab it fast
Yonder stands your orphan with his gun
Crying like a fire in the sun
Look out the saints are comin’ through
And it’s all over now, Baby Blue
The highway is for gamblers, better use your sense
Take what you have gathered from coincidence
The empty-handed painter from your streets
Is drawing crazy patterns on your sheets
This sky, too, is folding under you
And it’s all over now, Baby Blue
All your seasick sailors, they are rowing home
All your reindeer armies, are all going home
The lover who just walked out your door
Has taken all his blankets from the floor
The carpet, too, is moving under you
And it’s all over now, Baby Blue
Leave your stepping stones behind, something calls for you
Forget the dead you’ve left, they will not follow you
The vagabond who’s rapping at your door
Is standing in the clothes that you once wore
Strike another match, go start anew
And it’s all over now, Baby Blue
Here are links to two other Dylan classics: the "Subterranean Homesick Blues" video from 1965 and "Like A Rolling Stone" (studio version) and "Like a Rolling Stone" (live performance), the original recording from 1965. Dylan turned 72 on May 24, 2013. He is still recording new music and playing concerts around the world. You can learn more about Dylan at his website.
If the above video from The New Yorker with
Joyce Carol Oates does not work, try this link.
Joyce Carol Oates does not work, try this link.
Oates on Fiction
In an interview with The New Yorker, June 24, 2013, Oates has this to say:
Interviewer:
There’s been quite a bit of discussion lately about the notion of likability in fictional characters—and whether female writers are under pressure to consider it more than male writers are. It’s difficult to sympathize fully with either of these two characters [in "Mastiff"]. You refer to the woman in the moment of crisis as “the sort of woman you pity even as you inch away from her.” Do you feel you need to like—or, at least, sympathize with—a character in order to inhabit him or her for the space of a story?
Oates:
I sympathize with—and identify with—all sorts of people. I think that there is a measure of hypocrisy in those who profess surprise at flawed characters in fiction—virtually everyone is flawed, and everyone is, at one time or another, ignoble. The concept of a “hero” is unreal and of little interest. Also, we fall in love with imperfect people—some of us with actual criminals, murderers. This is a fact of life. Only in fiction are individuals supposed to be perfect—a woman must be “beautiful” to be a protagonist. In life, virtually anything goes. I think it should be thrilling—it should certainly be encouraging—to be assured that people who are deeply flawed can be nonetheless socially and sexually “successful,” admired, and beloved. If only perfect people were loved, where would that leave the rest of us? It’s hypocritical to expect of others that they be perfect when we know how imperfect we are ourselves. Maybe that’s a delusion of our species, an aspect of denial.
Interviewer:
Is it different if you’re writing a novel?
Oates:
In a novel, it is expected that people will change, over a period of time. The concept of change in personalities is fascinating—one sees definite change in young people, less obvious change in older people. (This is why so many of us like to teach: we can effect change—one hopes, for the better.) The novel is a sort of laboratory experiment in which numerous elements and conditions are brought together with results that should be both inevitable and somewhat unexpected. A short story is, by definition, a short “take,” but it may summarize a life, or it may suggest a life to come. In “Mastiff,” a woman and a man come together—somewhat unexpectedly to both. Under other circumstances, they might not even have liked each other; now, they are going to make a life together. If you don’t think that a marriage can begin in such a way, you are either not being honest or you haven’t had much experience. A marriage like this can be a very good one, since both wife and husband know that they will have to work hard to achieve the relationship: it didn’t come “naturally.”
Oates is Interviewed
Here is a selection of interviews with Oates: The Telegraph, The Washington Post, The Paris Review, Tavis Smiley and C-SPAN. The last two interviews are videos.
Oates and her Influences
In her interview with Salon, Oates discusses her influences: "The great influences that came into my life when I was in my 20s, I suppose. James Joyce is a great influence in many ways. The Joycean sentence, the way Joyce combines different senses, the way he looked at the world. Oddly enough, Joyce never wrote, as you know, about violence in any way. He said he abhorred violence. He never wrote about that. But there is a kind of domestic violence in Joyce’s writing. So Joyce is certainly an influence. Kafka was a strong influence and Lewis Carroll — 'Alice in Wonderland' and 'Through the Looking Glass' — the sensibility I really identified very much with Lewis Carroll. The sense of the absurd, a sort of comic absurd."
Joyce Carol Oates in the ring with World Heavyweight Champion Mike Tyson in Catskill, NY, Fall,1986. At the time Oates was working on her book On Boxing. Here is a selection from it. She also reviewed Tyson's Undisputed Truth.
Dylan's song shares a mood with Oates’ story because there is that sense of leaving abruptly and taking only what you most want. I also thought Oats may have purposely alluded to this song when the stranger calls her baby blue even though she had brown eyes.
ReplyDeleteMagdalena M,W 7:00 AM
I think the song and the Oates story shared a mood because in both there is a feeling of leaving, and only taking the thing that you feel is the most precious to you.
ReplyDeleteKary m/w 7:00
I do agree, Dylan in his song does not give the girl he is talking to an option. The song's name is "It's all over now, baby blue," giving off the impression that the girl has gone through some stress. The same way in the book, Arnold Friend gives off the impression that he is taking the girl away from the struggles she has had to deal with.
ReplyDeleteIn response to the Jazz music by sonny:
Believe it or not, I was taught to listen to this kind of music and symphonic music whilst I study. Some of my older teachers told me it was proved that listening to these kinds of music increases a student's ability to study.
I also read the story while I played the songs and tried to make it seem as though Sonny Clark was actually Sonny in the story and it worked out very well.
They seems share certain mood,fantasy vs reality, daydreaming?
ReplyDeleteLing Fung M/W 7.00am
i think in a sense that yes the song and where are you going where have you been shares the same mood. In the book the main character is in a way leading to her end just by crossing the "highway" that's in the song and the highway from i'm guessing maidenhood to adulthood. it can also depict time and the transition from childhood to adulthood feels like almost instant when you look back. As a child it would seem that adulthood is far away but as an adult when you look back it seems like yesterday that you were playing in the park
ReplyDeleteDylan's song is about someone leaving him and he kind of tell them that person that don't worry about him. In Oates' story and his song might be related due to someone is leaving as well. Because Connie wasts her mother to leave..? I think.
ReplyDeleteKimberly J.
Eng1B 7-9
Love the Sonny Clark Trio!
ReplyDelete-Elva Zepeda-Earnhart
English 1C
Nice to see all of you jumping in, no matter which class you're in.
ReplyDelete--Christopher McCabe
Dylan's song is about leaving with your most valuable things in life, and it sounds like that someone is "luring" another person to leave and leave other things behind. It corresponds to Connie's leaving which is convinced by Arnold.
ReplyDeleteHi prof. My name is Chris from M-W class at 7am for Engl 1B.
ReplyDeleteI was absent on last Wednesday and I just saw the syllabus that we actually will be having our first essay on Monday.
May I know what essay would it be about or if there is any prompt that I missed on Wednesday? thank you..
Hi Chris,
ReplyDeleteIs it Chris Johana? (Please include your class and full name. Thanks.)
As it turns out class is canceled for Monday. We'll likely have class on Wednesday, and if we do the exam will be held then.
Here are the things to keep in mind: know all of the literary terms that appear on the syllabus for classes from 2/28--3/2, including the literary terms mentioned in the paragraph on formalism, on page 1288.
Apply these terms to the stories by Ellison, O'Brien, Baldwin and Oates.
The specific prompt, though, has yet to be written.
Bring a blue book. Bring your textbook, but it will not be an open book exam.
--Christopher McCabe
yes, it is. Thank you so much for the info, prof.
ReplyDeleteI like the recording of Kevin Conroy. His voice is beautiful and warm. The girls statements before the song make listeners think about their most precious things in life. The song going after creates an peaceful atmosphere helping listeners go deeply. The recording also has a connection with the story in which Sonny and the narrator regretted and the meaning of the family reunion.
ReplyDeleteEnglish1B-10h30
I found out that the Batman one was actually interested. Like Batman is the one that live in the "Darkness" which mention in the story a lot of times. The loneliness and living(being active) in the dark matches the life of Sonny.
ReplyDeleteI love Ethel Waters - Am I Blue-1929 Film!! it remind me of my favorite shows "I love Lucy" and "Charlie Chaplin"! The smooth alto voice of the singer remind me of the lost decades that was replaced now with 3D movies, HD sound system, and sex. What happen to the good ol' days where kids can have entertainment without the extra junk (cuss words, violence, and sex on screen)?
ReplyDeleteIt also remind me of the good high school days when I was in jazz band. looking back when the group perform in the park, school, and dance event it was almost like i was sucked into the another time. especially with a dance event. from the small stage that my friends and I had to perform, i had a privilege of seeing old and young couples dance. females wear skirts that billows like a cloud when they were twirled and males wear pant suits and crisp dress shirts.
Eng1B mon-thurs Winter2012
I was looking forward to hear Billie Hollidae's cover of this song. Even though she did a great job, my favorite version would have to be Ray Charles. With its gloomy melody and melancholy lyrics, that emotion and sorrow can be easily felt within his voice. That is why he has been referred to many times as "the pioneer of soul music...." This song did an outstanding job of showing just that...However Prof., I too was unable to find the instrumental version of this song that you were looking for.
ReplyDeleteP.E. Winter 2012-ENG 1B
I like the song "Make You Feel My Love" written by Bob Dylan. The lyric is both romantic and beautiful in the sense that the lover is willing to make sacrifices for the happiness of his/her love one. I truly love the lyric, however, it's hard to follow Dylan's raspy voice, so I went on to search for more videos, and I found covers of the same song. Artists like Garth Brooks, Adele, Sam Kelly, and Dan & Kari Ballesteros have made great cover of the song; however, there is one cover video of the song that stands out to me and that is a duet by Arden Cho and Gerald Ko:
ReplyDeletehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QhZTPyopPSw
Original Song Sung by Bob Dylan:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ql2qlO8HH20
Great post, thanks! Here is some great footage of Dylan as a younger man (playing one of my favorite songs):
ReplyDeletehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3a3ERxzuh80
Hello Kim and Anonymous, Thanks to both of you for your tips.
ReplyDeleteWow! What an interesting woman! She has such an extensive list of literature works she has done. I am very impressed and now want to read one of her novels called Black Girl/White Girl!
ReplyDeleteThe story "Where are you going, where have you been" was the first story that made me want to know more. I found the story both chilling, compelling, and even sometimes confusing.
Overall I really enjoyed her writing style and enjoyed the story!
Cynamon, Happy to hear you are intrigued by Oates. I hope you like Black Girl/White Girl. When you get around to it, let me know what you think of it. A few years ago, sometime in the fall of 2011, a former student of mine, a veteran, had returned to the Middle East. (He wasn't disclosing his location, hence my vague place reference.) He had some downtime and wrote to me about Oates, and remembered reading "Where are you going, where have you been?" while in 1B. Back in the Middle East he picked up a novel by Oates called WHAT I LIVED FOR. I don't know how he came upon it, but he loved it and recommended it. I have yet to get to it, since I gave my copy away. Time to reorder it and put it on my reading list. It's another one of her big ones. 600+ pages. I won't forget my student, a really good guy, somewhere in the Middle East, picturing him reading a big, thick Oates novel in a dry, hot desert land. Only a year or so earlier he was sitting in my classroom, the second seat near the door. I am happy to say he is back home, married, and he and his wife have a baby girl.
DeleteMichele Raad, Destiny De La Torre, Gissella Galvan (group 7)
ReplyDelete1) Why did Oates choose to add Ellie to the story?
2) How did Arnold know so much information about Connie?
3) What happens to Connie after she leaves with Arnold?
Group 2
ReplyDeleteKevin A
Petal G
Sabrina H
Jesus
1. What do the #s 33,19,17 represent?
2. Why didn't she wait for her parents?
3. How was he able to find details about Connies life?
4. Why did Allie have the phone ready to call?
Group 3
ReplyDeleteNery Munos
Kenny Vong
Valery Dominguez
1. Did Arnold Friend literally "stab" her?
2. How did Arnold Friend know what Connie's fanmily was doing?
3. Do you see any similarities between Arnold Friend and Connie?
4. What do you think happened to Connie after the ending?
Group 1: Mia Sanga, Mia Yang, Diego Ramirez, June Phan
ReplyDelete1) what makes Connie give in to Arnold?
2) how does Arnold Friend lure Connie not to call the police?
3) how did Connie finally go with Arnold?
4) why does the author keep mentioning that Arnold Friend uses the expression and song from the year before?
Group 6 Chris, Julian, Jett
ReplyDelete1. Arnold seems to know lots of information that seems to make it seem too creepy to be true (Connie's name, location, where the rest of her family is). From this, do you think the series of events actually happened to Connie or was it too surreal?
2. Connie notices strange details in the way that Arnold dresses. What specifically are they? What do they suggest about his personality and age?
3. Connie's feelings of detachment from her family is what drove her to want to chase boys. However, when Arnold throws himself on her doorstep, she refuses. Why? Isn't this what Connie wanted all along?
Group 5-Bea Boy, Selicia Hou, Ariana Cleary, Oscar Diaz
ReplyDelete1) why would Connie even go with Arnold ?
2) who exactly is Arnold, is he a human or some other worldly creature ?
3) why did Arnold bring Ellie?
4) did Arnold really take Connie away or did she commit suicide ?
Group #4
ReplyDeleteAltina Arakelian, Rebecca Padilla, Joanna Aragon, Nicholas Anduaga
1) Did Arnold Friend murder the women down the road?
2) How did Arnold Friend find Connie's house?
3) Was Connie already dead when she saw the land setting at the end?
4) Why didn't Eddie notice Arnold Friend in the begging waving and talking to her?
Excellent questions!
ReplyDelete